The Giver 4/21/16
The part in The Giver that I read was when Jonas and the Giver were making a plan for Jonas to escape to Elsewhere, while the Giver was telling Jonas the plan Jonas wanted the Giver to come with him but the Giver said no because he wanted to spend time with his daughter named Rosemary. I think that the Giver should and should not go with Jonas because Jonas might get lost on his way to Elsewhere and the Giver will not be at the ceremony to tell everyone where Jonas is. Since Rosemary is the Giver's daughter is she the one who wanted to be released ten years ago???